Where To Get The Best Key Lime Pie In Key West

The one dessert that Key West is famous for is the Key Lime Pie. No trip to Key West is complete without having a taste of this delicious dessert. The sweet, creamy and tangy pie filling combined with a crumbly crust and sometimes a sweet fluffy meringue, creates a combination that everyone loves.

It’s such a classic in the Florida Keys that nearly every restaurant or bakery has their own version of the pie. Then of course, there are shops dedicated just for this dessert where you can pick and choose the kind of version of the pie you want to try.

It’s hard to choose “the best” Key Lime Pie since that is very subjective to personal tastes. But we have put together a list of the top places where you can try this pie in Key West. If you feel like there’s a place that should be on this list, let us know!

Kermit’s Key Lime Shop

Ketmit’s is one of the most well-known and popular Key Lime Pie shops in Key West. They have their own production of pies in various different styles. You can get a classic pie or pie dipped in chocolate, strawberry key lime pie and other variations of the classic.

This pie shop is also where you can get a gluten free Key Lime Pie in Key West for those who can’t have gluten in their diet. Not only do they have variations of the dessert, but they have Key Lime themed products like tumblers, candles, and honey.

You can’t miss the brightly colored yellow and green building for a stop in for the pie. There are actually three different locations with two locations right on Duval Street.

Key West Key Lime Pie Company

At the Key West Key Lime Pie Co, you get fresh pies every day from a 100-year old recipe. They use all-natural ingredients, real key lime juice and a handmade graham cracker crust.

On their menu they have whole pies, slices, chocolate dipped, mini pies, and pie in a cup. They also have a gluten free option here at this shop so it’s another gluten free option spot.

If you’ve ever wondered how to make a Key Lime Pie, they have a pie making class where you can make your own mini pie and learn all of the best pie recipe secrets.

Key Lime Pie Bakery

A locally owned and operated bakery is the place to go for fresh Key Lime Pie. They also have a large selection of souvenirs and other products like cakes, cookies, quick mixes, salt water taffy and tea all key lime themed.

It’s considered the original birthplace of the pie many years ago in 1856. So if you want a truly historic location, be sure to stop by this one.

Limes And Pies

Limes and Pies is a fun little stop for some Key Lime Pie. They sell homemade pies here and various other products including cookies, honey, and candies. They have a specialty Key Lime ice cream too that is delicious.

To go with your pie or ice cream, you can order a coffee drink there too and enjoy it out on the terrace looking out to the street.

Blue Heaven

One of the most famous places in Key West to eat Key Lime Pie is Blue Heaven. It’s famous for its sky high meringue on top of the Key Lime Pie.

This restaurant is the perfect place for breakfast or brunch in Key West where you can order something to eat along with your pie. The ambiance of the place and the chance to have Key Lime Pie with chickens and roosters makes it a special stop.

Better Than Sex

The Better Than Sex restaurant is known for its desserts and intimate atmosphere. For a slightly elevated experience while getting a taste of Key Lime Pie, visit this dessert dining experience.

Along with their regular menu, this location in Key West also has the island classic pie. Currently their version of the dessert combines Tiramisu and Key Lime Pie, using ladyfingers with a creamy key lime mousse and curd.

Pepe’s Cafe

Pepe’s Cafe is known as the oldest eatery in the Florida Keys and second oldest in the State of Florida behind the Columbia restaurant in Tampa. It’s a rustic little place serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

On the menu they have a wide variety of dishes on their menu including seafood and meats. Be sure to ask about their free slice of Key Lime Pie if you purchase an entree.

Moondog Cafe

Moondog Cafe is located next to the Hemingway House in downtown Key West. It’s a relaxed setting with options for breakfast, lunch or dinner. The colorful house is filled with bright murals, lights, and a garden-like atmosphere on the patio.

Their bakery offers different tartlets, pastries, cakes and pies on their menu. The Key Lime Pie is perfectly balanced with a sweet and tart taste and a burnt meringue on top. For those who follow a different diet, they do offer a mini vegan/gluten free version of the pie with a key lime coconut curd.

Sunset Pier

At this relaxed dockside eatery, you have the chance to have a meal and try their version the Key Lime Pie. Enjoy the dessert with beautiful views of the water and sometimes even live music.

The pie here is known more for its creamy, almost cheesecake-like texture. It’s a famous hang out spot out on the water and their is no better place than to sit here and enjoy the breathtaking views with a delicious dessert.

Seaside Cafe At The Mansion

If you don’t come here for the lobster pizza, come here for the Key Lime Pie. They have a classic pie on the menu as well as a Pina Colada Key Lime Pie giving it a fun new twist.

Experience their oceanfront dining that is open to the public, not only guests of the hotel.

La Grignote

La Grignote Cafe and Bakery is a delicious spot for breakfast and lunch. They serve salads, sandwiches and pastries with beautiful presentation and fresh ingredients.

The Key Lime Pie dessert here comes baked in a mini circle that’s perfect for one or for two to share. If you’re there for dessert, be sure to also get their honey cake to go along with your pie.

Old Town Bakery

The Old Town Bakery is a beloved local bakery known for its freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies and pies. Its award winning Key Lime Pies have been voted as some of the best on the island.

The bakery is housed in a charming 19th century building on Eaton and Grinnell Streets. Everything is baked on-site using the freshest ingredients.

Locals and visitors like to stop by here to get a pastry with a brewed coffee to go. It’s open daily in the mornings to mid-afternoon.

Latitudes

At Latitudes you get upscale fine dining with beautiful views of the water. Its located on Sunset Key that is accessible by a ferry that takes you to this beautiful resort.

It’s a special place to explore especially during sunset time and the dining experience there doesn’t disappoint. Afterwards, you can order a memorable slice of Key Lime Pie that has a rich creamy filling, a graham crust, and that fluffy white meringue served with a dollop of a berry sauce.

Banana Cafe

Banana Cafe on Duval Street isn’t just loved for its French-Caribbean breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a specialty in crepes. It also serves a delightful Key Lime Pie that comes with a tangy raspberry sauce and whipped cream.

Since they also specialize in crepes, they have a crepe version of Key Lime Pie where they fill a crepe with key lime sauce and whipped cream.

Kaya Island Eats

If you come to this restaurant for the delicious fish tacos, jerk chicken, or conch fritters, be sure to try the Key Lime Pie here too. Many people say they’ve got one of the best pies on the island and they’re not wrong.

This pie has a very creamy soft filling and a fluffy meringue on top that’s not too tall but enough to add to the flavor. It has a very thin crust to where you still get some of that crunch and it nicely compliments the rest of the pie.

Mattheessen’s

Mattheessen’s is a handcrafted dessert spot that serves up Key Lime Pie, cookies, fudge and ice cream. Their pies have a thick homemade graham cracker crust and an authentic filling from the finest ingredients.

Their Duval St. location is worth a stop by when you are in Key West. Their second location is in Nashville so if you’re ever traveling through Tennessee, you can still get an authentic Key Lime Pie.

Key Lime Pie Festival

A quick mention of the Key Lime Pie Festival is important when talking about Key Lime Pie in Key West. You can expect to find all kinds of key lime desserts there and different variations of the pie.

There’s a Key Lime cocktail sip and stroll, pie hop, mini pie making, pie drop, brunch and dinners as well as the exciting Key Lime Pie eating championship.